CIO Teardown 04 · Storage

The invoice line nobody explained

A growing law firm kept asking why its SharePoint storage bill got bigger every year. Everyone had the same answer: you’re making more data. Nobody asked what was actually filling the space.

The number

$7,116 a year.

That’s what a law firm was paying for storage on top of what their plan included. Let’s be honest about it: that’s not a scandal. It’s roughly $500 to $600 a month for years of client files, at a firm that was growing in staff and clients. That’s a good problem to have.

The problem was that nobody could explain it. The line kept growing, the client kept asking why, and the answer never changed.

SharePoint storage cost: $7,116 a year on a storage line nobody could explain
Figures from the engagement; the client isn’t named.

What was on the table

The client’s question was really frustration: “Why does our bill keep getting bigger?”

They’d added an in-house IT person, who didn’t have the experience to dig into it. The engineer on our side had 20 years in the field and didn’t do much better. Both landed on the same answer: “Your bill grows with the amount of data you create.”

That answer is true. It ends the conversation. And it’s the answer a reactive shop is trained to give: answer the question that was asked, raise the storage cap a little, close the ticket.

So that’s what kept happening. The cap went up a little at a time, and the frustration stayed.


What I did instead

I was the director at the managed services firm on this account, and I stepped outside the easy answer. We’d been slowly raising the cap for a while. Fine. But what exactly was eating through it?

We measured the tenant live with PowerShell and Microsoft Graph.

4.5 TB
in the tenant, 96.8% full
97%
of it in one site, across 1.85 million files
97.6%
of those files never opened
2018
version history unlimited since

Most of that archive just sat there. The files that did get touched told the story. They were old client files. Paralegals and lawyers opened them to pull information into new case files, which is exactly how a law firm should work. But every one of those trips created a fresh save, and with version history unlimited, every save was another full copy on the bill. Nobody was changing the old files. They were paying to store them over and over anyway.

The ticket asked why the bill was going up. The better question was what was filling the space.


What we changed

Not more storage. We adjusted the versioning, so the firm keeps the versions people actually restore and pulling from an old file stops quietly paying for another copy of it.

For the storage they did need, I recommended a $58-a-month staged buy instead of the $107 to $134-a-month option. The bigger option would have made my own firm more money. It wasn’t the right call for the client.


What should have been asked

What is this line on the invoice? If nobody can explain a recurring charge in one sentence, nobody is managing it. The size of the number matters less than whether anyone understands it.

What’s actually using the space? Not “data.” Which site, which files, how old, and how people work with them.

How many versions are we keeping? Every saved version counts against your storage. Microsoft’s own planning guide says its automatic version limits cut version storage by about 96% over six months compared with keeping a fixed count.1 Your plan includes 1 TB plus 10 GB per license; everything past that is bought on top.2

Who benefits from the bigger purchase? When the person recommending more storage also sells it, ask to see the smaller option.


Where this came from, and what my stake is. I was the director of a managed services firm when this happened. The client isn’t named and won’t be. Today I sell managed IT through Cybertitans, which means I could sell you storage too. Ask me the same questions. They work without me.

Ten questions to ask about your storage bill

  1. What’s every recurring line on your Microsoft invoice, and who can explain each one in a sentence?
  2. How much SharePoint storage does your plan include, and how much are you buying on top?
  3. Which one site is using the most space?
  4. How much of what you store has been opened in the last year?
  5. What’s your version history limit, and when was it last changed?
  6. Do you know how much of your storage is old versions rather than current files?
  7. How do your people reuse old files, and does that create new copies?
  8. When your bill went up last time, did anyone tell you why in plain English?
  9. When someone recommended buying more storage, did you see the cheaper option?
  10. Does the person recommending the purchase make money on it?

Does this sound like something happening in your organization?

If you’ve asked “why does this bill keep going up” and heard “because you have more data,” that’s the conversation. No pitch.

This is the work: asking the second question, not just answering the first one.

Book 20 Minutes
Sources
  1. Microsoft Learn, plan version storage on document libraries. Versions count toward storage; automatic version limits reduce version storage by about 96% over six months compared with count limits. Plan version storage
  2. Microsoft Learn, SharePoint limits. Total storage per organization is 1 TB plus 10 GB per license purchased. SharePoint limits